Imágenes de páginas
PDF
EPUB

Do we need a national theatre?
An expedition in the land of words
A perfectly satisfactory hero
The art of letter-writing
Childhood myths

Helen of Troy's diary

The theatre in 1616

An hour with the dictionary

Dogs in literature

How to use the library

Heroes: Achilles, Palamon, Ivanhoe

Everyman, a morality

Play-tricks and conventions

Louisa M. Alcott

Samuel Johnson

Hans Andersen

Thoreau

[blocks in formation]

The literary art of Macaulay

The songs of Scotland

More, an old time dreamer

The Cook's tale (Chaucer) retold for children

Stray thoughts about play-going

A typical work of the eighteenth century
Lady Macbeth

The art of seeing things

Rab and Bob, Son o' Battle

The historical novel

The works of Henty

Self-cultivation in English

National songs

The ideal king

Manhood ideals: Macbeth, Banquo, Macduff

Walden

Good magazines and bad

The secret of Burke's power

The maxims of Edmund Burke

Thoughts from Gray's Elegy

The good and the bad in Macaulay's style

The manufacture of plays and stories

My favorite author

Milton's unreproved pleasures

My favorite play

Readers, old and new

Robinson Crusoe

Gentlemen of the old school: Sir Roger and Dr. Primrose

Goldsmith as story-teller

Athletic contests of long ago

Tragic heroes: Macbeth and Brutus

Æsop

The kingly traits of Arthur

Mark Twain

The love of nature as seen in David's psalms
Story children

Juvenile literature

Review of Last of the Mohicans, Oregon Trail, Bottle Imp, The Great Hoggarty Diamond, Kenilworth, David Copperfield, Mill on the Floss, An Old Fashioned Girl, The Wide, Wide World, Deephaven, Captains Courageous, Waverley, the works of J. M. Barrie

11

Should cartooning the president be prohibited by law? Should a senator be guided by his own judgment or by the wishes of his constituents?

Do national expeditions pay?

Is Macaulay a greater writer than Burke?

Is the Ben Greet idea correct?

Should children read Mother Goose literature?

Is the Conciliation speech a proper classic for seniors to read? Are Shakespeare's heroines satisfactory?

Is Jack London a nature fakir?

Should the Old Testament be studied in public schools?
Do we need an endowed newspaper?

Should class day be abolished?

For general culture, which offers the greater inducements, a classical college or a scientific school?

Would it be well for the debating club to devote one meeting each month to non-argumentative literary exercises?

Is the interest in high school athletics declining? If so, why? Should sewing be made a compulsory study for high school girls?

Should all high school boys be made to take a course in carpentry?

Which offers the greater inducements, Annapolis or West Point?
Is a general education best for one who is to be a musician?
Should modern novels be read in classroom?

Is a college course necessary for a business career?
Should the prophecy be dropped from the class day program?
Which shall it be, office or drafting room?
Which shall it be, normal school or college?

E

A SPECIMEN BRIEF

This specimen brief, of Lord Chatham's speech on his motion for the immediate removal of the British troops from Boston, is taken, by kind permission, from Professor Baker's Specimens of Argumentation. Perhaps those of high school age should not be expected to prepare elaborate briefs; yet there are times when it is convenient to have at hand a trustworthy model.

INTRODUCTION

I

The present course of the Ministry suggests unfairness.

II

The Ministry has been guilty of unfairness, namely of misrepresentation, for

(a) Their representations that led to the passage of the measures obnoxious to the American people have been proved false, for

(1) The ministers said that these measures would overawe the Americans, but the measures have solidified the resistance of the Americans.

III

Therefore, the troops should be immediately withdrawn from Boston.

IV

But a hearer, in considering this attempt at justice, should remember that to try to be just to America is not necessarily to exempt her from all obedience to Great Britain

BRIEF PROPER

I

The removal of the troops is necessary, because

A. It will show the willingness of the English to treat amicably.

B. The resistance of the Americans was necessary because
I. The obnoxious acts of Parliament were tyrannical.
C. The means of enforcing the measures of Parliament have
failed, for

I. The army of General Gage is "penned up-pining in
inglorious inactivity."

II. The objection that the presence of this army in Boston is a safeguard is untrue, for

(a) It is powerless, and held in contempt.

(b) It is an irritation to the Americans.

(c) The objection that General Gage is needlessly inactive is untrue, for

(1) Any activity on his part would mean "civil and unnatural war."

D. If Parliament tries by the aid of the army to enforce its measures, the result will be bad, for

I. If Parliament were victorious, it would be over an embittered people.

II. The troops are not strong enough to resist three million united, courageous people.

III. Persecution of these men whose fathers left their

homes to escape it should cease, since

(a) The objection of the Ministry that the Americans "must not be heard" is unjust, since

(1) It "lumps the innocent with the guilty."

E. The statement that "the union in America cannot last"

is untrue, for

I. The evidence of the so-called "commercial bodies" is unreliable, for

(a) They do not really represent the class for whom
they profess to speak,

(b) And they are paid agents of the Government.
(c) Even if they did represent the commercial class of
America, their judgment would be untrustworthy,
for

(1) Not the commercial class, but the farming
class, are the strength of a nation;

(2) And the American farmers are unitedly arrayed for liberty.

II. The evidence of an authority (Dr. Franklin plainly

hinted) proves that the Americans, for the sake of liberty, would endure far more than they have as yet suffered, even war and rapine.

F. The statement that the Americans should be punished for illegal violence is untrue, for

I. A chance for reconciliation should not be missed.

II. Thirty thousand in Boston should not be punished for the fault of forty or fifty.

III. Punishment means arousing the unappeasable wrath of the whole American people.

IV. Even if the English people are victorious, they cannot control the great tracts of conquered country.

V. The resistance should have been foreseen, for

(a) The spirit that resists in America is that of all English stock, that which established the essential maxim of English liberty, "No taxation without the consent of the taxed."

VI. The resistance will become too strong to be overcome, for

(a) The English Whigs will aid them, for

(1) The spirit that moves the Americans is that which has always belonged to the Whigs.

(b) The Irish will aid them, for

(1) They have always maintained the ideas the Americans support.

(c) The means to oppose this united body is weak, for

« AnteriorContinuar »